MENU

To Pay or Not to Pay?

When shops close but the lease goes on...

Local firms – as much as international corporations – find themselves pondering these days more and more frequently, whether they can or cannot suspend lease payments for their shops, restaurants now temporarily closed due to the menace of the coronavirus epidemic.

Lessees expect the courts — in light of the present situation – to be reluctant to resolve any dispute in favor of lessors. Yet, the situation is not that clear cut. Certain legal issues shall be considered before making any assumptions.

Based on written lease agreements, lessee is to pay the amount of lease specified in the contract, on the one hand and the lessor is obliged to enable the use of the leased premises, on the other.

It goes without doubt, however, that an unexpected pandemic is an external circumstance that turns the payment of due lease fees illogical. Yet, stores can presently stay open even under certain statutory limitations and offices can still be operational despite the statutory changes of the past weeks. So, it actually is a question whether the courts would in the future recognize the present situation —uniformly, for all cases — as a force majeure that exempts lessees from their respective lease payment obligations (unless the parties expressly agreed otherwise, which seems rather unlikely) and eventually resort to the highly rarely invoked provisions of the Civil Code that relieve lessees from lease payment as long as the premises cannot be used due to circumstances beyond lessee’s sphere of control. However, if courts acknowledge a ’pandemic grace period’, it would mean a one sided total shift of obligations to lessors (maintenance costs, debt service, etc), while depriving them from the only source of income from real estate: the lease payment.

Accordingly, the question is rather whether any lessee’s expectation would be realistic to place all financial burdens stemming from the present situation on the lessors, despite valid lease agreements that are still in place. Not to forget, lessors generally tend to exclude any liability for their lessees’ turnover and profit and when the parties signed their lease agreements, lessee accepted and agreed to such exclusion of liability.

Therefore, the problem leads us to consider where exactly should be set the fine lines for a force majeure/contract frustration; whether a statutory quarantine has the same legal consequences as a partial closedown of a store (e.g. from 3 pm in the afternoon). Who bears the risk of a sudden drop of customers — if the loss is triggered by a statutory order, or by the individual decision of the management to instruct remote working and this is what caused substantial decrease in profit. As of today, it is hard to predict anything with full legal certainty, but for sure there will be court decisions which grant the lessee full exemption from lease payment, whereas there will be others, which grant partial relief and some others that do not exempt lessees, at all. For this reason, the present situation calls for a thought after and considerate approach, as well as a suitable way of communication/negotiation between the parties.

All in all, we recommend lessees to consider if
(i) their contract includes a force majeure clause, which can be applied favorably
to support them,
(ii) their lessor is currently in default of any of its contractual obligations,
meaning that lessees should better understand whether or not based on their specific contract they can indeed claim contract frustration and invoke a statutory force major clause, i.e. unexpected circumstances beyond the parties control.

Dr. Péter Garancsi is Managing Partner at Jádi Németh Attorneys at Law

Dr. Péter Garancsi

No comment yet. Be the first!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

eleven + eighteen =

  • Top 5 Articles


  • Articles by Date

  • Hashtags

    #Abel Prize #Academy #Academy Awards #Accenture #Accident #acquisition #Adrian Ellis #Advanced Power AG #Adventure #Advertising #Advertorial #Aerospace industry #Afghanistan #Africa #Agency #Agrarian industry #Agreement #Agricultural machinery #agriculture #Ahna Capri #air cargo #Air traffic #Air transport #air travel #Airbus Helicopters Hungary Ltd. #Airline industry #Airplane Gizi #airport cargo #Albania #Alberto Vercelli #Aldi #Alexander Tolkach #Aliza Bin-Noun #Allison Transmission Ltd. #Ambassador David B. Cornstein #Ambassador David Nájera #Ambassador Kumar Tuhin #Ambassador Massimo Rustico #Ambassador of India #Ambassador of Malaysia #Ambassador of the Republic of Korea to Hungary #Ambassadors #Ambassadors in Budapest #AmCham #American Airlines #American football #Amos Oz #Andersen Consulting #András Simor #Andrea Jádi #Andrew G. Vajna #Angela Merkel #Angola #Animals #Ankita Sood #Anna Nánási #Anna Olasz #anniversary #Annual report #Antal Rogán #Antal Vöneki #Anthony Nolan foundation #Antro Moveo #Apple Design Awards #Ararat #archeological excavations #Archeology #Armenia #Arms trade #Arraiolos Group #art gallery #Art Hall #Art treasure #ASEAN #Association of Immortal Hungarian Athletes #aston martin #Astronomy #Athlete of the Nation #Attila Grandpierre #Attila Mesterházy #Audi #Audi Hungaria #August 20th #August 20th national holiday #Australia #Austria #Automobile industry #Automobile sales #automobile trade #automotive #Automotive industry #Automotive sector #AutoWallis Group #Avatar #Aviation industry #Award #Azerbaijan
    #bag tag #bakery #Balassagyarmat #Balaton #Bálint gazda (Master Bálint) #Ballet company of Gyõr #Bálna event center #Baltic Sea Festival #Baltic states #Ban Ki-moon #Bank for International Settlements #bank loan #Bank of China #Bank transfer #Banking #Banking sector #Banking system #banknotes #Barack Obama #BASF #basketball #battery production #BBC #Beer #Béla Bartók #Belgium #Bell Food Group #Benelux #Best of Budapest and Hungary #BHS Trans Limited #bicycle #bilateral agreement #Bilateral relations #Bio ethanol #Biotechnology #Bisnode Hungary #Bisserka Benisheva #BKV #BMW #BMW cars #BMW Group #Boglárka Kapás #Bond issue #bond market #book festival #book review #border crossing #BorderLINE Architecture #Bozsik Stadium #brandy #Brazil #Brazilian Development Bank (BNDES) #Brexit #British Ambassador #British Chamber of Commerce in Hungary #British Council #British Telecom #Broadband internet #Bronislaw Komorowski #Budapest #Budapest Airport #Budapest Airport Co. Ltd. #Budapest Chamber of Commerce and Industry (BKIK) #Budapest City Branding Nonprofit Ltd. (BVA) #Budapest Eurogames 2012 #Budapest Festival Orchestra #Budapest film #Budapest Fire Service #Budapest ghetto #Budapest Highland Golf Club #Budapest hospitals #Budapest Jewish Community (BZSH) #Budapest Marathon #Budapest Mayor Gergely Karácsony #Budapest Millennium Underground #Budapest Opera Ball #Budapest Sports Office #Budapest Stock Exchange #Budapest Strings Chamber Orchestra #Budapest Week Publishing #Budapest Zoo #Buddhism #Budget policy #Bulgaria #Bundesliga (Austria) #burglary #business #Business club #business costs #Business Council for Sustainable Development in Hungary (BCSDH) #Business Council for Sustainable Development in Hungary’s (BCSDH) #Business environment #Business promotion #Business services #Businesspeople #Busójárás #Butterfly Garden
    #cable car #campaign financing #Canada #Canadian Chamber of Commerce in Hungary #Cancún Climate Summit #Canoe #capacity increase #Capital Circus of Budapest #car market #car racing #car rental #car sales #car sharing service #Car trade #Card payments #Carl Bildt #Carnival season #cars #Cartel #Cash #Cash payment #CEE region #Celldömölk #Census #Center for Budapest Transport (BKK) #Center of Excellence #Central Europe #Central European Initiative #Central European Press and Media Foundation (Kesma) #Central European University #Central European University (CEU) #Central Statistical Office #Ceremony #CERN #Cervantes Institute #Cetelem Bank #Chamber #Chamber of commerce #Chang Sun Dong #Charbel Stephan #Charity #Chemical Industry #Chemistry #chess #Chief Medical Officer Cecíla Müller #Chief Medical Officer Cecília Müller #China #Christian Mühlethaler #Christmas #Chung-ha Suh #CIG Pannonia Life Insurance Plc. #cinema culture #Citibank #City diplomacy #Civil Movement #CLA 250 e Coupé #CLA 250 e Shooting Brake #climate change #CMS Cameron McKenna #cobot #Code of Civil Procedure #Colleen Bell #Colliers International #Colorful City Group #columbia #Commemoration #Commemorative coin #Commerce #Commercial accommodation #Communications #Competition #Competitiveness #Concert #Conference #Conscious Consumption #Constitution #Constitutional Court #Construction industry #Consuls #Consultancy #consumer confidence index #contemporary art #contest #Convention tourism #Convertiplane #COP26 #Cordia #Corinthia Hotel Budapest #coronavirus #Corporate issues #corporate merger #Corporate real estate #Corporate social responsibility (CSR) #Corruption #countryside #Courts #Covid-19 coronavirus #Covid-19 pandemic #Crime #Crisis management #Croatia #cronyism #Csodalámpa (Magic Lamp) Foundation #Csopak #cultural festival #cultural institute #Cultural Interview #Culture #Customer service #customs service
    #e-mobility #E.ON #East Central Europe #Easter #ECOFIN #Economic forecast #economic reform #Economic relations #Economic sentiment index #Economy #Edit Herczog #Education #Eger #Egypt #Eisberg #EIT Health #Elderly home #Elections #Elections in Hungary #Electric charger #Electricity #electricity industry #Electro-mobility #Electrolux #Electronic industry #Electronic payment #Electronic Payment Service Providers’ Association (EFISZ) #Electronic Payment Strategy (EPS) #Electronics industry #Eleni Tsakopoulos-Kounalakis #ELTE #EMEA region #Emergency #Emigration #Emmy Awards #Employees’ rights #Employment #Enda Kenny #Endre Szemerédi #Energy industry #energy policy #energy security #Energy supply #Engineering #Enikõ Gyõri #Enrique Pastor de Gana #Environment #environment protection #Eörs Szathmáry #epidemic #Epidemiological preparedness #epidemiological restrictions #Equifest #Ernõ Rubik #Erste Bank #Ervin Zádor #Esther Horvath #Eszter Cseke and Andras S. Takacs #Esztergom #Ethanol #EU #EU affairs #EU cooperation #EU funding #EU funds #EU General Court #EU loan #EU Presidency #EU supported projects #EuCham - European Camber #Eucham European Chamber #Euro (EUR) #Europe Day #European Automobile Manufacturers Association (ACEA) #European Capital of Culture #European Central Bank (ECB) #European Championships #European Climate Bank #European Commission #European Court of Justice #European Court of Justice (ECJ) #European Day of Parks #European Football Championship #European Green Deal #European Institute of Innovation and Technology (EIT) #European Molecular Biology Organization (EMBO) #European Parliament #European Union #European Year of Volunteering #Eurowings #evacuation #Exchange rate #Exhibition #Exhibition site #Export promotion #Exports #Exposition #External Action Service of the European Union #External trade
    #H-UNCOVER #Hableány (‘Mermaid’) river cruise ship #Hackathon #Haiti #Hamad International Airport #handball #Hankook #Használtautó.hu #Health #healthcare #Healthcare workers #Heavy industry #Heim Pál National Pediatric Institute #Heineken #HEINEKEN Hungária #Henkel #Herbert Fisch #Herman Van Rompuy #Hidden Power #Hillary Clinton #History #Hódmezővásárhely #Holiday season #Hollywood #Holocaust #Home office #Home quarantine #Homokhátság #Honorary consul #Honorary consuls #Horizon Development #Hörmann Hungária #horticulturist #Hortobágy National Park #hospital #Hospitality #Hospitality business #Hospitals #Hotel boats #hotelier #hotels #House concert #Household products #Housing #Housing market #Hoventa #huawei #Human rights #Hungarian Academy of Sciences #Hungarian Academy of Sciences (MTA) #Hungarian Ambassador to the U.S. #Hungarian Banking Association #Hungarian Chamber of Health Care Professionals (MESZK) #Hungarian cultural season #Hungarian Democratic Forum (MDF) #Hungarian diplomats #Hungarian economy #Hungarian EU Presidency #Hungarian European Business Council (HEBC) #Hungarian F-1 Grand Prix #Hungarian Film Week #Hungarian Foreign Ministry #Hungarian Foreign Ministry (Ministry of Foreign Affairs and Trade) #Hungarian forint (HUF) #Hungarian GDP #Hungarian gov't vs. EU #Hungarian government #Hungarian Independent Trans­mission Operator Company Ltd. (MAVIR) #Hungarian industry #Hungarian Interchurch Aid #Hungarian inventors #Hungarian Investment and Trade Agency (HITA) #Hungarian Investment Promotion Agency (HIPA) #Hungarian Labor Code #Hungarian language #Hungarian Maltese Charity Service #Hungarian Medical Chamber #Hungarian military #Hungarian Ministry of Finance #Hungarian Ministry of Foreign Affairs and Trade (KKM) #Hungarian Museum of Science #Hungarian Museum of Science Technology and Transport #Hungarian National Asset Management Inc. (MNV) #Hungarian National Gallery #Hungarian National Museum #Hungarian Olympic Committee (HOC) #Hungarian Open Air Museum #Hungarian Parliament #Hungarian President János Áder #Hungarian Press Photo Exhibition #Hungarian society #Hungarian Tourism Agency (MTÜ) #Hungarian-born #Hungarians abroad #Hungaricum #Hungaroring #Hungary #Hungary tourism #Hungexpo #hybrid car #Hygiene #Hyundai
  • © Copyright 2020 Duax Kft. –  All rights reserved.
    searchenvelope-oalign-justifytwitterfacebookfeedinstagrammoon-osunearth